Connect with us


No, IIHS Doesn’t Recommend Monster Trucks for New Drivers



Image for article titled No, The IIHS Isn't Recommending 'Monster Trucks' for Teen Drivers

Photo: Andrew Collins

When shopping for a car for a teen driver, safety is usually the top concern for parents, and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety is a solid resource. Unfortunately, some outlets think that publishing crash statistics for small cars is the IIHS’s way of saying parents should buy their kids an Escalade. Here’s why that’s a lousy conclusion.

In August, the IIHS published a report that highlighted the dangers of teens driving smaller, older cars.

More than a quarter of teen drivers killed in crashes during 2013-17 were driving micro, mini or small cars, and nearly two-thirds were driving 6-15-year-old vehicles, indicating almost no change compared with 2008-12. In both periods, fatally injured adults crashed in newer, larger vehicles much more often than teens.

Data on vehicle miles traveled from the 2017 National Household Travel Survey also suggest teens tend to drive older cars than adults, though the survey doesn’t include information about vehicle size. Teens logged more than half of their miles in vehicles more than 11 years old, compared with less than 30 percent for adults, the survey found.

“It’s understandable that parents don’t want to shell out big bucks for their teen’s first car, and they probably don’t realize how much safer a newer, larger vehicle is,” says IIHS Research Scientist Rebecca Weast, lead author of the paper. “Small vehicles don’t protect as well in a crash, and older vehicles are less likely to be equipped with essential safety equipment.”

Naturally, anyone with a basic understanding of physics or a modicum of common sense would understand this. The reality is, when two objects collide, the object with more mass wins. To give parents some guidelines, IIHS and Consumer Reports teamed up and put together a list of 65 new and used cars (the latter, all available under $20,000) considered “safe” based on crash test results and available safety equipment.

If you scroll the list, you’ll note that IIHS and CR actually stick with reasonably-sized suggestions. The biggest vehicles you’ll find on the list are large sedans (like the Toyota Avalon), midsize SUVs (like the Toyota Highlander), or minivans (like the surprisingly large Honda Odyssey).

But somehow, StreetsBlogUSA interpreted this as the IIHS encouraging parents to buy their teens “Megacars.” The photo accompanying StreetsBlog’s article says it all: Apparently, they’re under the impression that most parents are oligarchs, paying six figures to put their kids in a Mercedes G-Wagen.

In response to IIHS data that shows higher fatality rates among teen drivers in small cars, StreetsBlogUSA is under the impression that following the advice to buy a safe car for your new driver will naturally lead to the deaths of pedestrians and cyclists.

“[Small] cars, though, are actually among the safest on the road … for people who walk and roll. Studies have long shown that megacars are two to three times more likely than a sedan to kill a walker in the event of a crash, and today’s hulking SUVs are a staggering eight times more likely to kill a child who isn’t behind the wheel.”

First of all, “Megacar” is not really a category of car. Second, the large SUVs and pickup trucks StreetsBlog is referring to never even show up on the IIHS recommended list.

StreetsBlog indicates that the IIHS has “backtracked” the recommendation for parents to choose bigger cars, but in their eyes, IIHS didn’t go far enough:

“Young hesitated, though, to withdraw the Institute’s recommendation outright, emphasizing that the negative effects of putting kids in monster trucks could be offset by other policies….”

At no point in either the IIHS report nor the Consumer Reports post was a “Monster Truck” ever recommended. In fact, not one pickup truck is on the list. The largest vehicle is a minivan.

America clearly has a problem with pedestrians and cyclists getting killed on our roadways. And much of it has to do with the proliferation of large SUVs and trucks. There’s a way we can reduce teen driver fatalities and pedestrian deaths: better driver training. However, just because a parent chooses a safer vehicle for their teen’s first car, doesn’t mean they’re indifferent about the safety of people around them. We don’t have to make this another us-versus-them fight.

Continue Reading

Recent News

Ethereum Investments Ethereum Investments
Crypto4 hours ago

From HODL to Wealth: Mastering Ethereum Investments

Cryptocurrency investors have witnessed the meteoric rise of Ethereum, making it a formidable contender in the digital asset market. Ethereum’s...

The Night Agent Season 2 The Night Agent Season 2
Entertainment4 hours ago

The Night Agent Season 2: Release Date, Cast, Production Details, and More Explored

Are you waiting for the release of The Night Agent season 2? The action thriller show is based on a...

Bilan Liu Bilan Liu
Tech7 hours ago

Design Alchemy: Bilan Liu’s Journey of Creativity and Connection

In the midst of modern design’s hustle and bustle, Bilan Liu is a shining star of ingenuity and artistry. As a...

Restaurant Furniture Restaurant Furniture
Home Decor8 hours ago

From Bistros to Brasseries: Commercial Restaurant Furniture Styles for Different Dining Concepts

Setting the tone for an outstanding dining experience for your guests extends beyond the food. It has to include every...

NetReputation Reddit NetReputation Reddit
Digital Marketing8 hours ago

NetReputation Reddit: Best Online Website Management Service

Are you a website online that is exhausted of the constant, round the clock website management as well as maintaining...

Jennifer Garner’s Net Worth Jennifer Garner’s Net Worth
Celebrity8 hours ago

Jennifer Garner’s Biography: Personal Life, Net Worth, Lifestyle and More

Janet Anne Garner is an American actress who was born on April 17, 1972. From 2001 to 2006, she played...

James Cameron Net Worth James Cameron Net Worth
Celebrity8 hours ago

James Cameron Net Worth: From Blockbuster Movies To Deep-Sea Exploration

James Cameron is a name that needs no introduction come on. As a filmmaker, explorer, and innovator, he has left...

Kaceytron's Net Worth Explored Kaceytron's Net Worth Explored
Celebrity8 hours ago

Kaceytron’s Net Worth Explored: How Much Does The Twitch Streamer Earn?

Kaceytron has carved out a prominent position in the world of live streaming, captivating audiences with her personality and engaging...

Caitlyn Jenner’s Net Worth Caitlyn Jenner’s Net Worth
Celebrity8 hours ago

What Is Caitlyn Jenner’s Net Worth?

Caitlyn Jenner, the diva who got famous through her work on Keeping Up With The Kardashians, has a lavish life,...

Sylvester Stallone’s Net Worth Sylvester Stallone’s Net Worth
Celebrity8 hours ago

Sylvester Stallone’s Net Worth, Career, Lifestyle, and More

Sylvester Stallone is an actor, writer, producer, and director from the United States. He is now one of the most...